State pensioners across the UK have received startling letters from HMRC demanding up to £10,000, triggered by misapplied “emergency” tax codes on one-off pension withdrawals.
The practice, which taxes lump-sum withdrawals as if they were monthly income, has led to widespread overcharging—prompting thousands to chase refunds.
What’s Going Wrong?
- Under pension freedoms introduced in 2015, defined contribution pension holders over 55 can withdraw 25% tax-free, with the rest taxed as regular income.
- However, HMRC often applies an emergency ‘month‑1’ tax code on the first withdrawal—assuming it’s a recurring monthly income—which results in excessive tax deductions.
- This error has prompted numerous “incredible” tax bills, some reaching £10,000 or more.
Refunds—By the Numbers
| Category | 2023–24 Figures |
|---|---|
| Pensioners claiming refunds | ~60,000 (20% year-on-year increase) |
| Claimed refunds ≥ £5,000 | ~11,700 pensioners |
| Claimed refunds ≥ £10,000 | ~2,400 pensioners |
| Average refund per claimant | £3,342 (up £280 or +9% year-on-year) |
| Top 25 refunds average | £106,900 each |
| Total refunded since 2015 | Over £1.4 billion (now stretching to ~£1.5bn) |
| Q2 2025 refunds | £48.7 million to 12,767 claimants (~£3,815 avg) |
Why the Issue Persists
- Faulty Emergency Tax Assignment
HMRC’s system still wrongly applies emergency tax codes on initial lump-sum withdrawals. Only from April 2025 was an overhaul introduced to update tax codes more quickly—but it does not prevent the initial overcharge. - Shock to Retirees’ Finances
Experts describe these sudden deductions as a “massive shock”, derailing retirement plans and causing significant stress. - Still Requires Action for Refund
Though automated corrections are underway, pensioners must still file specific forms (P55, P53Z, or P50Z) to secure refunds—processing time is often within 30 days, but requires proactive steps.
The “incredible” £10,000 tax demands issued to pensioners reflect systemic flaws in HMRC’s approach to emergency tax on pension flexibility.
With tens of thousands affected—including many who received substantial refunds—it’s clear that retirees must remain vigilant. Completing the proper refund forms and consulting financial advice are critical steps in mitigating these unintended financial burdens.
FAQs
Because HMRC misinterprets one-off lump sums as recurring monthly income under the emergency tax code, causing excessive withholding.
You can file an HMRC form—P55 (partial withdrawal), P53Z, or P50Z (full withdrawal)—to claim a refund, often processed within 30 days.
Yes. Although systems have improved since April 2025 to update tax codes faster, the initial withdrawal still uses emergency coding, meaning the problem may persist unless you pre-emptively manage it.
0 Comments